$$ Nieuw Amsterdam, 106-112 Hardware Street, Melbourne




Nieuw Amsterdam is described as a classy New York-style bar and eatery, serving creative cocktails and gourmet American diner food. It’s a bit more low key located on Hardware Street which is directly opposite the hustle and bustle of Hardware Lane, so you’d have to know it was there opposed to being wooed by the hawkers outside restaurants on Hardware Lane.









#6 – Californian Tuna – sesame, cucumber, soy, edamame


This dish sounded delicious and it was! If anything it was just lacking as Manu would say on my kitchen rules…. THE SAUCE! Perhaps if the sauce was over the top of the fish it would have had more impact but we just didn’t get enough of it! The fish was fresh and sealed beautifully.


          Usually            Score          Order

          Order?              /10          Again?

E       Yes                    8              Yes

B       Yes                    8              Yes






#3 – Grilled Trevally- pickled mussels, fennel, tomato, smoked paprika


It didn’t sound exciting on the menu but it was beautifully presented and wow the flavour combination really packed a punch, quite fishy but in a really good way, it was delicious! Points were deducted for the trevally being a tad dry, slighly overcooked, otherwise it would have been 10/10 all round.


          Usually            Score          Order

          Order?              /10          Again?

E         No                   7.5            No

B        Yes                   9.5            Yes






#4- Borrow Dale Pork Ribs -apple, radish & kohlrabi slaw


Elaine loves her some pork ribs! I on the other hand not the biggest fan, maybe because I haven’t had many but these were delicious, super tasty marinade and the serve was very generous. They teamed up fantastically with the slaw. The scores say it all, we would definitely head back for these!


          Usually            Score          Order

          Order?              /10          Again?

E       Yes                   10             Yes

B        No                   10             Yes






Dutch potato fries, sriracha mayo


Home-made real cut potato chips, exactly what Elaine (and the rest of the world loves!) you can’t go wrong and the dipping sauce was so tasty! YUM!


          Usually            Score          Order

          Order?              /10          Again?

E        Yes                   10             Yes

B        Yes                   10             Yes






#4 -Vanilla Donuts – strawberry sugar, jam & cream


The deconstructed donuts were a novel way of presenting them and if they were reminiscing on scones with jam and cream they did a good job, the donuts were a little doughy and more reminiscent of scones than donuts, so not the best ones we’ve had but edible all the same.


          Usually            Score          Order

          Order?              /10          Again?

E        Yes                   7              No

B        Yes                   7              No



The place has a great warm vibe with all the wooden tables and bar, a few nooks for different groups available. Can really see it bustling for after work drinks & food!

The menu isn’t large so it seems they can concentrate on perfecting what they have! Everything we had was delicious. The service was outstanding and we would definitely recommend a visit!


            Overall                  Back

          Score /10               Soon?

Elaine    9.5               Absolutely, YUM!

Bez       9.5               Absolutely, YUM!


Price: One Entree, One Main, One Pitt Grill, One Dessert

Total – $88.00 (Two People)

Tuna – $16.00 each
Trevally – $22.00
Pork Ribs- $29.00
Chips- $9.00
Donuts- $12.00

E & B xx


Nieuw Amsterdam Menu, Reviews, Photos, Location and Info - Zomato


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s